There's no
doubting that this season was a real roller-coaster for City fans, we
started with the permanent appointment of Neil Adams (despite having
ZERO experience and almost deliberately trying to get us relegated whilst
showing the board he could play for a draw against the likes of
Chelsea when a win was needed), this lead to an opening day defeat against Wolves, followed
by a strong run of results which saw us win 6 and draw 2 out of an 8
game run of form. However, this run of form couldn't continue and in
fact abruptly ended with a poor 1-0 home defeat against Charlton and
then dragged on for a 10 game period where we managed a single win
and 4 draws.
There was
another short upturn in form in December, with us winning 3 out of 4
games (including 5-0 and 6-1 results against Huddersfield and
Millwall), only for this to be halted again with a home defeat
against Reading just before the new year.
It was at
this point that rumours began stating that the NCFC board were
becoming very uneasy at Adams tenure and our somewhat worrying league
position at the time, and thus before the inevitable axe could fall,
Adams did the honourable thing and fell onto his own sword and
resigned on the 5th of Jan.
Rumours then
abounded about who would be chosen as his replacement, names from
across Europe, the UK leagues and even the unemployment centres were
touted around, and then from seemingly out of nowhere the club
appointed the relatively unknown Alex Neil from Hamilton Academicals,
a 33 year old former Barnsley player with just 2 years experience
under his belt as a manager!
I was
sceptical at first, in fact I was downright rude at times in regards
to the appointment (something I soon came to regret), and in truth I
couldn't have got it more wrong.
Neil's
appointment galvanised a squad that should have been challenging for
one of the automatic promotion slots instead of dithering around in
mid-table, into a side that looked capable of beating ANY team in the
league when on song, and thus began an outstanding run of results
where we lost just THREE games out of the next 25, culminating in a
3rd place finish and victory in the play-off final against
Boro. (Special mention should also go to stuffing Ipswich in the
play-off semi-final, which I'm sure delighted their fans just as much
as it did ours!).
It was a
truly outstanding turnaround that Neil accomplished, and indeed many
felt that he was just as worthy (if not more so) of winning the LMA
manager of the year instead of Eddie Howe, certainly if we were to
just base it on win %, then Neil would probably be rated as one of
the best managers in Europe (if not the world), with an incredible
68% win rate since taking the helm at Norwich.
But as
impressive as Neil's achievement has been, the work now has to start
on the season to come. A return back to the Premier League's riches
and crazy money means that squad improvement is going to be
essential, and we cannot afford to have another high profile failure
like we did last time with the signing of Ricky Van Wolfswinkel (who
I still rate as a good player who was badly misused by Chris
Hughton).
Notable
departures include back left back Javier Garrido, 3rd
choice Goalkeeper Mark Bunn, veteran centre half Carlos Cuellar and
'pinemaster' Luciano Becchio. In all honesty, the only player we're
likely to miss from those released is Garrido, as he offered
unspectacular cover for Martin Olsson in the LB position, and the
question here is whether Alex Neil is in the market for a new player
in the position (I like the look of either Baba Abdul Rahman from
Augsburg, or Arthur Masuaka from Olympiacos) or if he's going to show
faith in young Harry Toffolo who's impressed for both the U21 team
and whilst on loan at Swindon.
Indeed, it's
not just the left back position that's come under scrutiny from fans,
as over the season question marks have been raised about the ability
of both Russell Martin as a centre back and Steven Whittaker in the
right back position. It could certainly be argued that these concerns
are somewhat strange considering that we finished with the 3rd
best defensive record in the league, yet I also share some of these
concerns having seen some of the individual errors and mistakes that
the players may get away with in the championship, that they won't in
the Premier League.
Tottenham's
young USA starlet DeAndre Yedlin is one of the main names linked with
the RB position currently held by Whittaker, and this would certainly
give us great competition in the slot as well as offering us
incredible pace down that side.
In the
middle of defence however, far less names are floating around, and
although most fans would agree that a strong, ball playing centre
back should be one of the main targets on Neil's shopping list, and
whilst there are good young players out there like Niklas Sule,
Terence Kongolo and Jonathan Tah, it's likely that experience will be
preferable, with suggestions like Younes Kaboul being high on many
supporters own suggestion lists.
We have
already made two signings so far, by spending 4 million to make
Graham Dorrans loan move permanent, and we've also signed his West
Brom teammate Youssouf Mulumbu on a free transfer. I think both
represent excellent value for money and undoubtedly improve our squad
depth in the middle of the park, indeed Mulumbu will offer much
needed cover and competition for Alex Tettey who has been one of our
stand out players for the past couple of years, but who has struggled
with injuries on occasion.
With Jonny
Howson, Gary O'Neil and the fully fit again Vadis Odidja-Ofoe, the
centre of the pitch looks relatively well covered, but sadly this
isn't so much the case when moving out wide.
Clearly the
key player here is England U21 superstar Nathan Redmond, who's
continued improvement and superb performances for both club and
country are likely to have one of the bigger names in football come
knocking sooner rather than later. Indeed should Raheem Sterling
leave Liverpool to join Man City, early rumours suggest that a 15-20
million pound bid from Liverpool would likely be forthcoming for
Redmond's signature – a move that we seriously don't want to
happen.
All this
waxing lyrical about Redmond however shouldn't overshadow the player
who quite rightly won this years Player of the Season – Bradley
Johnson. Make no mistake, I've slated Johnson's passing accuracy and
technical attributes ever since he signed for the club (whilst
respecting his work rate, desire and attitude), but his movement out
towards the left hand side combined with vastly improved shooting
accuracy has made Johnson almost undroppable for us, and indeed his
15 goal haul from midfield is one of the key factors of our immediate
premiership return, and full credit has to be given to the guy for
this.
The problem
comes when one of these two wide players becomes injured/suspended,
leaving us looking VERY thin on the ground with replacements. Former
Brighton winger Elliot Bennett has managed just a handful of games in
the last 2 years due to injury and being out of favour, the young
Murphy brothers whilst possessing clear potential are simply not
ready for premier league football in my honest opinion, and Northern
Ireland international Kyle Lafferty has never convinced in a wing
role and is likely to be moved on anyway in the next month or so.
Reports
linking Swansea's Nathan Dyer with a move east look to be little more
than idle gossip at this stage, and despite my own personal
preference, I have to admit that it's doubtful that Man Utd will
allow us to bring Adnan Januzaj in on anything but a loan (if at
all), yet surely this would solve much of the wing issues, with the
player being comfortable on both wings as well as having the
potential to provide cover in a more traditional no 10 position for
the gracefully ageing Wes Hoolahan.
Alex Neil's
own signing from former side Hamilton, Tony Andreu has failed to
convince at all in the limited minutes he's played, but at the minute
he appears to be off the pace and not physically strong enough to
cope with the level he's moved to, but there's still plenty of time
for this to change going forwards.
Speaking of
forwards, this is the position that I think EVERY fan is concerned
about.
Cameron
Jerome is moving back into the prem after his best ever goalscoring
season, yet it's not unreasonable to question his ability to maintain
his excellent form, having previously failed to do so when playing at
that level for Stoke, Birmingham and Crystal Palace. I think we've
seen the player that Stoke and Birmingham fans knew was in there, but
couldn't seem to consistently appear, and if Alex Neil can keep
Jerome focused and scoring, it looks like one of the bargain signings
of the season (something to thank Neil Adams for I guess...)
Beyond this
you have the unknown quantity of Lewis Grabban at this level, and
seeing as how I question his finishing ability at a lower level, I
have serious concerns about what he can do in the prem. Indeed I can
easily see Grabban becoming the new Simeon Jackson – great effort,
great work rate, but not enough goals or quality to justify a regular
place.
We also have
a different option available in Gary Hooper, a player with clear
finishing ability and good movement, but who simply doesn't fit into
the target man role that Neil likes to play ahead of a midfield 5.
Whilst there may be some merit in suggesting a more withdrawn role
playing off Jerome or Grabban, it's clear that a front two is
something that Alex Neil doesn't favour unless we're chasing a game
near the end, when it could be 2, 3 or even 4 upfront!
I've also
got to address the elephant in the room, and that's record signing
Ricky Van Wolfsinkel. Loaned out to St. Etienne for the season with a
view to a permanent move afterwards, the 'Wolf' has failed to impress
his French suitors and returns to Carrow Road uncertain of what the
future holds. Talk has been mentioned of a return to Sporting Lisbon
– the club we signed him from and where his best goalscoring years
were found, and indeed this would seem a sensible move for the
player, to return to a club where he knows he can score and where the
fans still love him. Personally I'd like to see what he can do under
a manager that isn't trying to play him in completely the wrong way
in an utterly negative, defensive fashion, but much like Hooper, he
simply doesn't seem to fit into the style of play that Alex Neil is
expected to utilise again this season, leaving him as little more
than a very expensive bench warmer.
That leaves
us looking at potentially signing a left back, centre back, right
back, left winger, right winger and 2 strikers – not a cheap
shopping list when you have a fund of approx 25-30 million and are
looking to improve on what you already have rather than simply find
decent cover options.
Due to their
very nature, most of the time the lion's share of that expenditure
would be expected to be on a striker, and whilst options like Charlie
Austin provide a proven threat at this level, they come at a huge
price, and one which I think we can avoid.
We may have
been slightly burnt on the Van Wolfswinkel deal, but I firmly believe
that the continent is the place to shop when it comes to strikers.
Indeed, sides like West Ham and Swansea have shown what's possible
with signings like Sakho and Bony, and it's simply down to Neil and
the scouting team to get out there and see what they can find to fit
the bill.
We've also
already been heavily linked with Mulumbu's DR Congo teammate
Dieumerci Mbokani, and if we really wanted to look for a proven
premier league striker with great experience, then surely we need to
look no further than Dimitar Berbatov who's been released by Monaco
and is apparently looking for a move back to England. Clearly wages
would be massive, and he'd probably expect a multi-million pound
signing on fee (much like Swansea have reportedly paid nearly £6
million to Andre Ayew who they've signed this summer on a 'free'
transfer), but at least you're getting a proven entity with undoubted
quality and who has never relied on pace to perform – hence his
advancing age is less of an issue that it would be for a player like
Walcott for example.
It's early
days on the transfer side of things and we're all waiting expectantly
to see which players walk into Colney over the next month or so, but
with the core squad that's taken us back up, an outstanding young
manager with the desire and hunger to perform with the very best, and
a few shrewd signings thrown into the mix, I'm very confident that we
can not only stay up this season, but kick on from there and truly
establish ourselves back in the top flight again.